The power of storytelling in building client trust

Michael Summerton unpacks how you can unleash the power of storytelling to build trust, inspire, and drive lasting impact.

The power of storytelling in building client trust

Key points

In a world where data and analysis often dominate conversations, one timeless tool remains dusty and unused in the leadership toolbox: storytelling. Over the years, I’ve come to appreciate how a well-crafted story can inspire, influence, and build trust in ways that raw data alone cannot. It’s not just about communicating facts - it’s about creating a shared narrative that resonates emotionally, both within and outside the organization.

Why Storytelling Matters in Business

We often talk about KPIs, metrics, and performance benchmarks, but I’ve noticed that what truly sticks in people’s minds aren’t the numbers- they’re the stories behind those numbers. In leadership, we sometimes shy away from storytelling because it feels intangible or hard to measure. But here's the thing: storytelling, when done well, has a measurable impact - on trust, engagement, and business outcomes.

I recall attending a talk 15 years ago where the speaker told three stories that stuck with me vividly since that moment. I can recall the stories and the lessons more clearly than what i had for breakfast.  What was powerful wasn’t just the content of his presentation but the way he connected it to real-world lessons. If you can tell a story that people remember years later, that’s real impact.

Building trust through storytelling

One of the most valuable applications of storytelling in business is its ability to build trust. Trust isn’t built through bullet points on a PowerPoint slide - it’s built when people see themselves reflected in your narrative, when they feel connected to the journey you’re taking them on. In business, this can translate into shared ownership of goals and vision.

For instance, I’ve seen leaders struggle to motivate their teams with facts and figures alone. But when they frame those numbers within a larger story - one that shows the team how their individual efforts tie into the broader success of the company - it sparks something deeper. Suddenly, employees aren’t just cogs in a machine; they’re part of a shared mission.

Failure stories: a powerful tool for learning

There’s something compelling about failure stories, particularly in business. We’ve all heard the success stories, but the truth is that most of us learn more from our failures than our triumphs. In fact, I often find myself gravitating toward stories of things that didn’t go right - those are the ones that teach us the most.

In leadership, sharing stories of failure humanizes you and builds credibility. It shows your team that you’re not perfect, and more importantly, that failure is a stepping stone to growth and success. People resonate with those stories because they’re real - they’re raw, and they reflect the challenges everyone faces at some point.

Storytelling as a learned skill

One question I’m often asked is whether storytelling is an innate talent or a learned skill. I firmly believe that it’s the latter. Like playing an instrument or excelling in a sport, storytelling requires practice. I’ve met leaders who have a natural flair for public speaking, but upon closer examination, it’s clear they’ve honed this ability over time. They grew up in environments where communication was key, or they spent years practicing the art of narrative.

In business, the same principle applies. Whether you’re leading a small team or presenting to thousands, storytelling is a skill that can be developed. It’s about understanding your audience, crafting a narrative that speaks to them, and delivering it in a way that feels authentic to who you are.

Authenticity over polish

In an age of sleek presentations and polished pitches, it’s tempting to focus more on delivery than substance. But, quality content is king. Take, for example, the economist I once worked with. His delivery was awkward at best - he mumbled, paused in random places, and spoke softly. Yet people hung onto his every word because his authority and personal mastery on the topic were unparalleled.

This is an important lesson for leaders: while a polished presentation can grab attention, it’s the depth of your content that will leave a lasting impression. Your authenticity and expertise will always outweigh superficial gloss. Your audience will forgive the occasional stutter or awkward pause if what you’re saying truly matters to them.

Applying storytelling in your business

The applications of storytelling in business are vast, from inspiring your team to building trust with clients and partners. Start by reflecting on your own experiences - what stories shaped your journey, what failures taught you valuable lessons, and how can you use these narratives to connect with your audience?

When crafting stories for your business, focus on these elements:

- Make it relatable: People need to see themselves in your story. The more personal and human the narrative, the more it will resonate.

- Build suspense: Don’t give away the punchline upfront. Let the story unfold naturally.

- Be authentic: Let your personality shine through. Authenticity is the key to connecting with your audience.

Ultimately, storytelling isn’t just about telling a great story - it’s about making people feel something, whether that’s inspiration, trust, or a deeper connection to your shared goals. When done right, storytelling becomes one of the most powerful tools in your leadership toolkit, driving both personal and business growth.